Born and raised in New York - some of my early adult holiday memories include traveling on the train all the way from the Bronx to Junior’s Cheesecake in Brooklyn to stand in ridiculously long (but surprisingly fast moving) line to pick up some cheesecakes for the Holiday table.
Junior’s Cheesecake is legendary, and for good reason. It’s just so damn good. I LOVE a dense, silky, and uncomplicated cheesecake and this cake delivers on all fronts.
When I was younger and made cheesecake I always included a graham cracker crust (for the added texture contrast) but the spongecake crust included here is authentic to my experience at a beloved institution.
I would suggest making this the day before. It’s definitely a labor of love but your efforts and PATIENCE will be rewarded with the most delicious cheesecake that can play canvas to any topping you desire. I used a cherry topping as that’s what I typically picked up when I went to Junior’s - 1 plain and 1 cherry!
A tip on patience. There are some things you can’t skip on: room temperature ingredients. In order to get that silky and creamy cheesecake batter you need to ensure that your cream cheese is at room temperature. If not, you’ll have little lumps of cream cheese throughout your batter.
Also, let it chill for at least 6 hours! I know - your kitchen will be smelling amazing from pulling out the cheesecake from the oven. But I promise you waiting enough time to let the cheesecake chill and set will reap it’s rewards when you go to slice in and get nice clean cuts!
Speaking of nice clean cuts - when ready to cut, use a very sharp knife (not serrated) and dip the knife in hot water for each cut and you will have perfectly clean cut each time. You know I’m all about the visual and presentation.
I hope you enjoy!
Melissa
The classic NY style cheesecake: dense, silky, creamy with a very clean cheesecake bite! Legendary!
Spongecake Crust
Cheesecake
Cherry Sauce
Equipment needed
To make the spongecake crust:
To make the cheesecake batter:
To make the cherry topping:
Leave a comment